One of the first questions to answer when looking for off-campus housing near BYU-Idaho is how you want to live: sharing a bedroom with a roommate, or paying more for a room entirely to yourself. Both setups exist in the Rexburg market, but they lead to very different budgets and everyday experiences. Here’s how they compare, and why shared rooms are the smarter choice for most BYU-I students. 

SCHEDULE A TOUR

Private Rooms

Private rooms give each resident their own bedroom, with no one else’s bed, desk, or closet space in the room. It comes at a premium, since one person is covering the cost of an entire room instead of splitting it. 

Shared Rooms

Shared rooms put two students in one bedroom, each with their own bed, desk, and closet space, while splitting the cost of that room down the middle. At Windsor Manor, every floor plan — the 6 Bed/3 Bath and 8 Bed/4 Bath apartments — is built around shared bedrooms, with each student sharing a bedroom and bathroom with just one other person. It’s a setup designed to keep rent affordable without sacrificing comfort. 

One of the first questions to answer when looking for off-campus housing near BYU-Idaho is how you want to live: sharing a bedroom with a roommate, or paying more for a room entirely to yourself. Both setups exist in the Rexburg market, but they lead to very different budgets and everyday experiences. Here’s how they compare, and why shared rooms are the smarter choice for most BYU-I students.

Factor Private Room Shared Room (Windsor Manor)
Bedroom Full cost, one person Split between 2 residents
Bathroom Full cost, one person Split between 2 residents
Rent Premium pricing Starting at $1,953/semester
Utilities Often separate All utilities included in rent
Furnishings Full cost, one person Fully furnished, shared between roommates

Because Windsor Manor prices every bedroom and bathroom for two residents, shared rooms keep rent predictable and split evenly — you’re never covering the cost of space built for someone else, and you’re never paying private-room rates for a shared setup. 

It’s built around community. BYU-I’s student culture revolves around wards, activities, and a close-knit social scene. Having a roommate right in your room makes it easier to build that community from day one, rather than coming home to an empty room every night. 

You’re never short on company. Moving to Rexburg for the first time can be an adjustment. A shared room means built-in company without having to go looking for it. 

You still get real personal space. Sharing a room doesn’t mean giving up comfort. Every bedroom at Windsor Manor comes with a walk-in closet, individual desk and chair, and your own bed with 30″ of underbed storage — you get a defined personal space within the room, without paying private-room rates. 

Roommate matching takes the guesswork out. Moving to Rexburg without a roommate lined up? Roommate matching pairs you with someone to share your bedroom, so you’re not left figuring it out alone. 

Pros of Shared Rooms 

  • Lower cost per person. Splitting a bedroom and bathroom between two residents keeps rent well below what a private room would cost. 
  • Built-in community. A roommate close by makes it easier to build the kind of social life BYU-I is known for. 
  • Real personal space within the room. Walk-in closets, individual desks, and dedicated storage mean you still have a defined space that’s yours. 
  • Fully furnished. Every shared bedroom comes furnished, along with shared access to a fully equipped kitchen and common areas. 
  • Utilities included. All utilities are bundled into rent, so a shared room keeps your monthly costs simple and predictable. 

Drawbacks of Paying for a Private Room 

  • Higher cost, no way to split it. A private room means covering the full rent for that bedroom by yourself. 
  • Less built-in community. Without a roommate close by, it can take longer to build a social circle in a new city. 
  • Harder to justify the premium. Most students paying for a private room over a shared one are covering costs for space they don’t necessarily need. 
  • You lose the shared-experience side of student housing. Part of what makes off-campus BYU-I housing memorable is doing it with roommates, not alone. 

Every apartment at Windsor Manor is designed around shared bedrooms, split by gender across separate men’s and women’s buildings: 

  • 6 Bed/3 Bath — 1,300 square feet, with each student sharing a bedroom and bathroom with just one other resident. Starting at $1,953/semester. 
  • 8 Bed/4 Bath — 1,500 square feet, same shared bedroom-and-bathroom setup across four bedrooms. Starting at $1,953/semester. 

Both floor plans come fully furnished, with a 55″ flat-screen TV, stacked washer and dryer, walk-in closets, and a walk-out balcony. All utilities are included in rent, and residents get access to a 24-hour gym, meditation room, activity room, theater/media room, community fireplaces, landscaped gardens, seven common areas with pool, foosball, and air hockey, 10 private study rooms, and 4 music practice rooms with pianos. Windsor Manor sits just a 30-second walk from BYU-Idaho campus.

SCHEDULE A TOUR

Do I actually share a bedroom, or just an apartment?

How much does a shared room cost?

Rates start at $1,953/semester for both the 6 Bed/3 Bath and 8 Bed/4 Bath floor plans, with all utilities included. 

What if I don't have a roommate lined up yet?

Are men and women housed in the same buildings?

No. Windsor Manor has separate men’s and women’s buildings. 

How long are the leases, and is a guarantor required?

Leases run 1 to 4 semesters. A guarantor is only required for residents younger than 18. 

How close is Windsor Manor to BYU-Idaho?

Windsor Manor is about a 30-second walk from campus, making it one of the closest off-campus options in Rexburg.